Chargebee Retention, formerly Brightback, is a cancel-flow tool. When a customer clicks cancel in your app, it shows a screen with offers such as a discount, a pause, an extension or a plan change, before the cancellation goes through. It works with Chargebee, Stripe and Recurly. It doesn't handle failed payments.
StripeReport is a Stripe reporting tool whose Pro plan sends failed-payment, expiring-card, cancellation and win-back emails. The two tools do quite different jobs, so for many businesses this isn't really an either-or.
The short verdict
Pick Chargebee Retention if
- Most of your churn is customers choosing to leave, and you want to catch them on the cancel screen.
- You want offers like pauses and plan changes shown before the cancellation completes.
- You bill with Chargebee or Recurly as well as Stripe.
Pick StripeReport if
- A lot of your churn comes from failed payments and expired cards.
- You want cancellation and win-back emails without adding anything to your app.
- You want a daily revenue report as well.
Side by side
| Feature | Chargebee Retention | StripeReport |
|---|---|---|
| Main job | Cancel flows with save offers | Stripe revenue reporting, plus emails that keep customers (Pro) |
| Failed-payment emails | ✗ (Chargebee Billing has its own dunning) | ✓ Within the hour, then day 3 and day 7, stopping when they pay (Pro); one-tap reminders (Reports) |
| Card expiry warnings | ✗ (Chargebee Billing has its own reminders) | ✓ About 3 weeks and 3 days before a renewal the card won't survive (Pro) |
| Cancel flow screen | ✓ Discounts, pauses, extensions, plan changes | ✗ No in-app cancel screen |
| Cancellation email | Check their site | ✓ One email while they still have access, with an optional offer (Pro) |
| Win-back email | Check their site | ✓ One email, 7 days after the subscription ends (Pro) |
| Revenue reporting | Retention reporting; check their site | ✓ Daily report by email and Slack, plus an MRR and churn dashboard |
| Billing systems | Chargebee, Stripe and Recurly | Stripe only |
| How pricing works | Not published; check with Chargebee | Reports: $14.99/mo flat. Pro: by your monthly Stripe revenue, from $49/mo |
| Setup | Cancel flow is added to your app's cancel button | Connect Stripe with read-only access; nothing to add to your app |
We make StripeReport, so we’ve kept to what Chargebee Retention’s own site says and left out their prices, which change. Check their site for what’s current.
Cancel flows vs cancellation emails
Chargebee Retention works at the moment of cancelling. The customer clicks cancel, sees a screen that asks why, and gets an offer that fits the answer. That needs a change to your app, but it catches people right when they decide.
StripeReport has no cancel screen. It works after the click: when a customer sets their plan to cancel and still has access, Pro sends one email asking what went wrong, with your optional offer and a button to keep their subscription. If they still leave, one win-back email follows seven days after the subscription ends. Nothing to add to your app. More on cancellation and win-back emails.
Failed payments
Chargebee Retention doesn't cover failed payments. If you bill with Chargebee, its billing product has its own dunning and card reminders. If you bill with Stripe, StripeReport's Pro plan emails customers within the hour of a failed payment, then on day 3 and day 7, and warns customers whose card will expire before their next renewal. How StripeReport recovers failed payments.
Using both
Because they cover different moments, some Stripe businesses could use a cancel-flow tool for people who choose to leave and StripeReport for failed payments, expiring cards and reporting. If you do, decide which tool sends the cancellation and win-back messages so customers don't hear from both.
Related questions
Is Chargebee Retention the same as Brightback?
Yes. Chargebee acquired Brightback in 2022 and it is now called Chargebee Retention.
Do I need Chargebee Billing to use Chargebee Retention?
Chargebee lists Stripe and Recurly integrations as well as Chargebee. Check with Chargebee for how it is sold today.
Does StripeReport show a cancel screen?
No. StripeReport sends emails. It has no cancel screen, reason survey or pause option inside your app.