Should I offer a discount when a customer cancels?

Updated

The short answer

Sometimes. A discount works when price is the reason people leave, and it should be temporary, such as a few months off, not a permanent cut. It does little when people leave because they stopped using the product. Offer it once, to the right customers, and watch whether those who accept it stay after it ends.

When a discount makes sense

  • Customers tell you price is why they're leaving.
  • Your product has a busy and a quiet season, and a cheaper few months gets them through the quiet one.
  • The customer has been with you a long time and has never asked for anything.

When it doesn't

  • They stopped using the product. Paying less for something they don't use won't keep them for long.
  • They're missing a feature or had a bad experience. Fix that, or at least acknowledge it.
  • You offer it to everyone, every time. Word gets around, and cancelling becomes the way to get a deal.

How to set it up

  1. Pick a temporary offer, such as 20% to 30% off for three months. Avoid a permanent discount: it cuts your revenue for good.
  2. Create it as a coupon in Stripe, and a promotion code if you want customers to type it.
  3. Mention it once, in the cancellation email or screen, with a clear end date. The Stripe customer portal's optional cancellation page can show a coupon like this to customers as they cancel; check your portal settings for what your account includes.
  4. After a few months, check how many people who took the offer are still paying once it ends. If most leave anyway, try a different offer.

Alternatives to a discount

A smaller or cheaper plan keeps the customer paying the right amount for what they use. A pause, which Stripe subscriptions support if your business can offer one, suits people who'll be back after a busy patch. Sometimes the best offer is simply a reply from you asking what went wrong.

Related questions

How big should the discount be?

Big enough to matter, small enough to stay profitable. Many businesses start around 20% to 30% for a few months and adjust from there.

Should I offer it before or after they cancel?

While they still have access is best, because staying is one click away. After the subscription ends, the same offer can go in a win-back email.

Will customers cancel just to get the discount?

Some will, if you offer it every time. Offer it once per customer and only for a limited time, and that habit doesn't form.