StripeReport vs Baremetrics Recover: Failed Payments Compared

StripeReport vs Baremetrics Recover: failed-payment emails, card expiry warnings, SMS, win-back and reporting compared, so you can pick the right fit on Stripe.

Facts about Baremetrics Recover checked November 2026

Baremetrics Recover is the failed-payment part of Baremetrics, the subscription analytics tool. It is sold as an add-on to a Baremetrics plan rather than on its own, and it sends dunning emails, optional text messages and in-app notices when a card fails.

StripeReport is a Stripe reporting tool with recovery emails built into its Pro plan, plus emails for expiring cards, cancellations and win-back. We make StripeReport, so we have tried to be fair, including about where Recover is the stronger choice. For a wider view, see our dunning software comparison.

The short verdict

Pick Baremetrics Recover if

  • You already use Baremetrics for analytics and want recovery in the same place.
  • You want text messages or in-app notices as well as email.
  • You bill through Braintree as well as Stripe.

Pick StripeReport if

  • You want failed-payment, expiring-card, cancellation and win-back emails without buying an analytics suite first.
  • You want a daily revenue report in your inbox and Slack, not one more dashboard to log in to.
  • You want a lower starting price that doesn't need a separate add-on.

Side by side

FeatureBaremetrics RecoverStripeReport
Main jobFailed-payment recovery, as an add-on to Baremetrics analyticsStripe revenue reporting, plus emails that keep customers (Pro)
Failed-payment emails✓ A series of emails over several weeks✓ Within the hour, then day 3 and day 7, stopping when they pay (Pro); one-tap reminders (Reports)
Payment retriesRelies on Stripe's Smart RetriesNone of its own: Stripe's Smart Retries do the retrying
Card expiry warnings✓ Emails before the card expires✓ About 3 weeks and 3 days before a renewal the card won't survive (Pro)
Cancel flow screenA separate Baremetrics product (Cancellation Insights)✗ No in-app cancel screen
Win-back emailCheck their site✓ One email, 7 days after the subscription ends (Pro)
Other channelsOptional SMS and in-app noticesEmail only
Revenue reporting✓ Baremetrics analytics dashboard✓ Daily report by email and Slack, plus an MRR and churn dashboard
Billing systemsStripe and Braintree for RecoverStripe only
How pricing worksAdd-on on top of a Baremetrics plan; check their pricing pageReports: $14.99/mo flat. Pro: by your monthly Stripe revenue, from $49/mo
SetupConnect your billing system to Baremetrics, then turn on RecoverConnect Stripe with read-only access; nothing to add to your app

We make StripeReport, so we’ve kept to what Baremetrics Recover’s own site says and left out their prices, which change. Check their site for what’s current.

Failed payments

Both tools email customers when a Stripe payment fails, and neither replaces Stripe's own retries. Recover sends a longer series of emails over several weeks, and can add text messages and in-app notices. It can also put up a paywall in your app after a grace period, which takes some setup on your side.

StripeReport keeps it shorter. On Pro, the first email goes out within the hour of the failure, with the reason the card was declined, Stripe's next retry date and a secure Stripe link to pay. Follow-ups go out on day 3 and day 7, and the emails stop the moment the customer pays. The wording changes with the decline reason, so someone with an expired card is asked for a new card, and someone short on funds is told when the card will be tried again. How StripeReport recovers failed payments.

Expiring cards, cancellations and win-back

Recover sends emails before a card expires. StripeReport's warnings are timed against the next renewal: if the card will run out before the customer is next charged, they get an email about three weeks before the renewal and a last one three days before if they haven't updated it. More on card expiry warnings.

For cancellations, Baremetrics has a separate product with a cancel screen inside your app. StripeReport has no cancel screen. Instead, Pro sends one email to a customer who set their plan to cancel while they still have access, and one win-back email seven days after the subscription ends. Whether Recover itself sends win-back emails is worth checking on their site.

Reporting

Baremetrics is a full analytics product, with deeper reports than StripeReport. If you need detailed cohort analysis or a team that lives in the dashboard all day, that matters. StripeReport sends you yesterday's revenue, MRR and churn every morning by email and Slack, with who signed up, cancelled or had a payment fail, by name, and a dashboard with forecasts and revenue at risk.

When Baremetrics Recover is the better choice

  • You already pay for Baremetrics and want everything in one tool.
  • You want SMS, in-app notices or a paywall after a failed payment. StripeReport is email only.
  • You need detailed analytics beyond a daily report and a dashboard.

Related questions

Can I buy Baremetrics Recover without Baremetrics?

Baremetrics sells Recover as an add-on to a Baremetrics plan. Check their pricing page for the current options.

Does either tool retry the card itself?

No. Both rely on Stripe's Smart Retries for the retrying and handle the messages to the customer.

Can I try StripeReport's emails before paying for Pro?

Yes. Every account gets its first five automatic emails free, and there is a 3-day free trial with no card needed.