Paddle Retain is the retention product that used to be called ProfitWell Retain, before Paddle bought ProfitWell. It recovers failed payments with its own retry timing, messages customers by email, in-app and text, and offers cancel flows with save offers. It comes included with Paddle Billing and is also sold on its own for other billing systems, including Stripe.
StripeReport is a Stripe reporting tool whose Pro plan adds failed-payment, expiring-card, cancellation and win-back emails. We make StripeReport, so we have aimed to be straight about where Retain is the stronger tool.
The short verdict
Pick Paddle Retain if
- You bill with Paddle, where Retain is included.
- You want retries timed by Retain, plus in-app and text messages.
- You want a cancel flow with save offers inside your app.
Pick StripeReport if
- You bill with Stripe and want simple, published prices that start small.
- You want a daily revenue report as well as recovery emails.
- You want win-back and cancellation emails without adding anything to your app.
Side by side
| Feature | Paddle Retain | StripeReport |
|---|---|---|
| Main job | Retention: failed-payment recovery and cancel flows | Stripe revenue reporting, plus emails that keep customers (Pro) |
| Failed-payment emails | ✓ Email, in-app and SMS | ✓ Within the hour, then day 3 and day 7, stopping when they pay (Pro); one-tap reminders (Reports) |
| Payment retries | ✓ Its own timed retries | None of its own: Stripe's Smart Retries do the retrying |
| Card expiry warnings | In-app prompts before cards expire; check their site for email | ✓ About 3 weeks and 3 days before a renewal the card won't survive (Pro) |
| Cancel flow screen | ✓ With save offers | ✗ No in-app cancel screen |
| Win-back email | Check their site | ✓ One email, 7 days after the subscription ends (Pro) |
| Other channels | In-app and SMS | Email only |
| Revenue reporting | Paddle has separate analytics; check their site | ✓ Daily report by email and Slack, plus an MRR and churn dashboard |
| Billing systems | Paddle, plus Stripe, Chargebee, Recurly, Braintree and others standalone | Stripe only |
| How pricing works | Included with Paddle Billing; standalone pricing on request | Reports: $14.99/mo flat. Pro: by your monthly Stripe revenue, from $49/mo |
| Setup | Connect billing; in-app features need code in your app | Connect Stripe with read-only access; nothing to add to your app |
We make StripeReport, so we’ve kept to what Paddle Retain’s own site says and left out their prices, which change. Check their site for what’s current.
Failed payments and retries
The biggest difference is retries. Retain runs its own retry timing, so it decides when the card is tried again. StripeReport leaves retries to Stripe's Smart Retries and focuses on getting the customer to act: an email within the hour of the failure with the decline reason, Stripe's next retry date and a secure link to pay, then follow-ups on day 3 and day 7 that stop when they pay.
Retain can also reach customers in your app and by text. StripeReport is email only, sent in your business's name, from your own address if you like, with replies coming to you. How StripeReport recovers failed payments.
Cancellations and win-back
Retain offers cancel flows: a screen in your app that shows an offer before the cancellation goes through. StripeReport doesn't. On Pro it sends one email to customers who set their plan to cancel, while they still have access, with your optional offer and a button to keep their subscription. If the subscription still ends, one win-back email follows seven days later. More on cancellation and win-back emails.
Pricing
If you bill with Paddle, Retain is part of what you already pay for. For other billing systems, Paddle doesn't publish standalone prices, so you will need to ask them. StripeReport publishes its prices: Reports is $14.99 a month flat, and Pro is priced by your monthly Stripe revenue, starting at $49 a month. See StripeReport plans.
When Paddle Retain is the better choice
- You use Paddle Billing, so Retain is already included.
- You want retries timed by a dedicated tool rather than Stripe's.
- You want cancel flows, in-app messages or text messages. StripeReport has none of these.
Related questions
Is Paddle Retain the same as ProfitWell Retain?
Yes. ProfitWell Retain became Paddle Retain after Paddle acquired ProfitWell.
Can I use Paddle Retain with Stripe?
Paddle sells a standalone version of Retain that works with Stripe and several other billing systems. Check their site for current details.
Does StripeReport change how Stripe retries cards?
No. StripeReport reads your Stripe account and sends emails. Stripe's own retry settings stay in charge of retries.