The short answer
Say what happened, why (in plain words), and the one thing they need to do, with a button to do it. Keep it short and friendly: most declines are an expired card or a bad week for money, not someone trying to avoid paying. The best wording depends on the decline reason, so use a different version for each.
The shape of a good declined card email
- Greet them by first name if you have it.
- Say what didn't go through: "We couldn't charge your card for Shiftbird Team ($49.00)."
- Give the reason in everyday words. Never use bank terms or words like "stolen".
- Ask for one action, with one button.
- Say when you'll try again, if you will.
- Sign off from a real person or your business, and let replies reach you.
Wording for each decline reason
- Not enough funds: "Your bank said there wasn't enough available on the card. We'll try again automatically on November 12. You can also pay now, or use a different card." Button: Pay now.
- Expired card: "The card on your account has expired. Add your new card to keep your subscription running. It takes a minute." Button: Update card.
- Wrong details: "Your bank didn't accept the card details we have, such as the security code or ZIP code. Enter your card again to keep your subscription running." Button: Update card.
- Card blocked or closed: "Your bank won't allow charges on this card any more. Please use a different card." Button: Use a different card.
- Bank wants approval: "Your bank wants you to approve this payment. Open the secure page below to approve it." Button: Approve payment.
A full example
Hi Sarah,
We couldn't charge your card for Shiftbird Team ($49.00). Your bank said there wasn't enough available on the card.
We'll try again automatically on November 12. You can also pay now, or use a different card, so your subscription keeps running.
[Pay now]
Thanks, the Shiftbird team
What not to say
- Don't threaten to delete their account in the first email.
- Don't paste the raw decline code. "do_not_honor" means nothing to a customer.
- Don't hint that they did something wrong. Most of the time, nobody did.
- Don't send them to log in and hunt for billing settings. Link straight to the payment page.
Related questions
Where do I find why a Stripe payment was declined?
Open the payment in your Stripe Dashboard. The decline code and Stripe's explanation are in the payment's details.
Should I tell the customer the exact decline reason?
Tell them what to do about it, in plain words. "Your card has expired" helps. "Your card was reported stolen" doesn't: for blocked cards, just ask for a different card.
How formal should the email be?
Write it the way you'd talk to a customer you like. Short, warm and clear beats formal and long.