The short answer
Three is a good default: one as soon as the payment fails, a reminder a few days later, and a last one about a week in, timed around your card retries. Stop the moment the customer pays. More than that rarely helps and starts to feel like nagging.
A simple schedule
Line the emails up with Stripe's retries, so the customer has just fixed their card when the next attempt runs.
- Day 1: what happened, why, and a button to pay or update the card.
- Day 3: a short reminder. Mention the next retry date.
- Day 7: the last reminder. Say plainly what happens if the payment doesn't go through.
When to stop
- As soon as the invoice is paid, whether by a retry or by the customer.
- When the email bounces. Keep emailing a dead address and it hurts how well your other emails arrive.
- When the subscription is canceled. From then on, a win-back email is the better message.
When to send more (or fewer)
Higher-priced plans, or customers who have been with you for years, can justify a personal note from you on top of the automatic ones. For low-priced monthly plans, three is plenty. If your retries run for several weeks, you can space the reminders out further, but keep the count about the same.
Related questions
Should the last email threaten to cancel the account?
Be clear, not threatening. "This is our last reminder. If the payment doesn't go through, your subscription will end" is fair and honest.
Is a text message better than email?
Some tools add SMS. Email works for most businesses, especially when it comes from a name the customer knows.
Should I email on the same day the payment fails?
Yes, within hours is best. The customer is most likely to act while it's fresh.