What subject line should a failed payment email have?

Updated

The short answer

Name your business and say plainly what happened: "Your payment to Shiftbird didn't go through" works better than anything clever. Be more specific when you know the reason ("Your card for Shiftbird has expired"), and make the reminders clearly reminders. Avoid anything that sounds like spam, a scam or a threat.

Subject lines that work

  • First email: "Your payment to Shiftbird didn't go through"
  • Expired card: "Your card for Shiftbird has expired"
  • Bank approval needed: "Please approve your Shiftbird payment"
  • Second email: "Reminder: update your payment for Shiftbird"
  • Last email: "Last reminder: your Shiftbird payment"

What to avoid

  • ALL CAPS, lots of exclamation marks, or "URGENT". They look like phishing and land in spam.
  • Threats in the first email, like "Your account will be deleted".
  • Vague lines like "Action required" or "Account notice" with no business name.
  • Dollar amounts in the subject. Keep the amount in the email itself.

Why plain beats clever

Customers have learned to be careful with emails about payments, because scammers send them too. A subject line that names a business they know and says exactly what it's about is the one they trust enough to open. Pair it with a From name they recognize and a link that goes to a secure payment page, never one asking for card details by reply.

Related questions

Should I use the customer's name in the subject?

It's fine in the greeting. In the subject, your business name matters more, because that's what tells them the email is real.

Should I use emoji?

Not for payment emails. They make it look like marketing, and this email needs to look like a trustworthy notice.

Does the From name matter as much as the subject?

Yes, often more. Use your business name, or "Your Business via a tool", so customers recognize it in their inbox.