The short answer
Usually, not much: let Stripe retry the card, and send the customer a short, kind note saying the payment didn't go through and when you'll try again. An insufficient funds decline means the card is fine but the money wasn't there that day, so a retry a few days later often works. Don't ask them to change their card unless they want to.
What "insufficient funds" means
The customer's bank declined the payment because there wasn't enough available on the card or account at that moment. Stripe shows it as the decline code insufficient_funds. Similar codes, such as a card that hit its spending or withdrawal limit, mean much the same thing.
Unlike an expired or blocked card, nothing is broken. The same card will often go through after payday.
What to do
- Make sure Stripe's Smart Retries (or your own retry schedule) is on, so the card is tried again over the next days.
- Email the customer once, soon after the failure. Keep it short and don't make it awkward.
- Tell them the date of the next retry, and give them a way to pay now or use a different card if they prefer.
- Follow up a few days later if it still hasn't gone through, and once more before the final retry.
- Stop all emails as soon as the payment succeeds.
Example email
Hi Sarah,
We couldn't charge your card for Shiftbird Team ($49.00). Your bank said there wasn't enough available on the card.
No problem: we'll try again automatically on November 12. If you'd rather pay now, or use a different card, you can do that here.
[Pay now]
Related questions
Should I cancel the subscription after an insufficient funds decline?
No. Give the retries and reminders time to work. Decide what happens after the final retry in your Stripe subscription settings.
Will retrying the card cost me fees?
Check Stripe's pricing for your account. Declined attempts and retries are part of how Stripe Billing works, and many businesses find retries worth it.
Should I offer a cheaper plan?
If the same customer keeps failing for funds, a gentle note offering a smaller plan or a different billing date can keep them as a customer.