The short answer
Good win-back subject lines are short, name your business, and say plainly what the email is: a question, an update or an offer. For example: "Come back to Shiftbird: 20% off your first 3 months" or "What could we have done better?". Avoid guilt, fake urgency and anything that looks like an invoice.
With an offer
- Come back to [Business]: 20% off your first 3 months
- Your [Business] offer: 3 months at half price
- A thank-you if you'd like to come back to [Business]
- [Business] is here when you're ready (plus 20% off)
Without an offer
- What could we have done better?
- We'd love to hear why you left [Business]
- Thanks for trying [Business]
- We fixed the thing you asked about
What to avoid
- Guilt: "You're making a mistake" or "We're heartbroken".
- Fake urgency: "Last chance!!!" when there isn't a real deadline.
- Looking like a bill: "Action required on your account" will get opened, then resented.
- All capitals and lots of punctuation, which look like spam to people and to email filters.
- Leaving out your name: the customer should know who it's from before they open it.
Make the rest match
A subject line only gets the email opened. The first line should keep the same promise, and the button should take them straight back. Our win-back email templates include full emails to go with these.
Related questions
Should I put the discount in the subject line?
If you have one, yes. A clear offer is a good reason to open. Keep the exact terms for the email itself.
Should I use the customer's first name in the subject?
It can help, but only if your data is clean. A subject that says "Hi null" or uses a company name as a first name does more harm than good.
How long should a win-back subject line be?
Short enough to read in full on a phone, which usually means under about 50 characters. Put the important words first.