How many win-back emails should I send?

Updated

The short answer

For most small subscription businesses, one well-timed win-back email is enough, perhaps followed by a single later check-in when you have real news. People who cancelled made a choice, and several reminders in a row tend to annoy them more than persuade them.

Why one email usually does the job

A win-back email works when the customer was on the fence: the timing was bad, the budget was tight, or something small went wrong. Those people respond to the first friendly message. People who left for good reasons rarely change their mind after the third.

Every extra email also carries a cost. Each one is a chance for someone to unsubscribe or mark you as spam, and spam complaints affect how well all your other emails arrive, including invoices and failed payment reminders.

When a second email makes sense

  • You've shipped the feature they said was missing.
  • Your prices or plans changed in a way that fixes their reason for leaving.
  • Their seasonal busy period is coming round again.
  • They replied to the first email and asked you to get back in touch.

When to stop

  • They unsubscribed or asked not to be contacted.
  • Their address bounced.
  • They didn't open the first email or the second.
  • Your message has nothing new to say.

Related questions

Don't marketing tools send five or six win-back emails?

Some do, and big consumer brands with huge lists can test that. For a small business with a few cancellations a week, a single thoughtful email is easier to get right and less likely to annoy.

Should the email include an offer every time?

No. Offers work best when price was the reason. If they left for another reason, an honest question and an easy way back may be enough.

How do I know if my win-back email works?

Count how many people who got it started a new subscription in the following weeks. Opens and clicks show interest, but new subscriptions are what count.