See for yourself in two minutes. How StripeReport compares with Baremetrics, ChartMogul and ProfitWell.
Try it freeShort answer: Stripe’s built-in dunning retries failed payments and can send standard emails to your customers. StripeReport does not retry payments. It adds the customer contact layer on top: emails in your own voice that explain why the payment failed, follow-ups on a set schedule, card expiry warnings, a “before you go” email, a win-back email, and a report of how much each email saved. Most businesses that use StripeReport keep Stripe’s Smart Retries switched on. The two work together.
“Dunning” just means chasing payments that failed. Below, we look at what Stripe already gives you, what StripeReport adds, and whether you need anything beyond Stripe at all.
What Stripe’s Built-In Dunning Does
Stripe Billing includes a good set of recovery tools. If you run subscriptions on Stripe and haven’t looked at them yet, start here before you pay for anything else.
Smart Retries
When a subscription payment fails, Stripe can retry it automatically. With Smart Retries, Stripe picks the retry times it predicts are more likely to succeed, rather than retrying on a fixed timetable. Many failures are temporary — a card briefly over its limit, a bank having a bad day — and a retry a few days later often goes through without the customer doing anything. You choose how many retries to allow and over what period in your Stripe Billing settings.
Stripe’s failed payment emails
Stripe can email your customers when a payment fails, with a link to pay or update their card. It can also email customers when the card on file is about to expire. You switch these on in your Stripe Billing settings, and you can add your logo and brand colours. These are functional, standard emails sent by Stripe. They do the job of telling the customer something went wrong and how to fix it. How much you can change the wording and timing depends on Stripe’s current options, so check your Stripe Billing settings for the details.
Hosted invoice page and customer portal
Stripe hosts secure pages where customers can pay an open invoice or update their payment method. That means you don’t have to build or maintain a card-update page yourself, and card details never touch your servers.
What happens after the last retry
You can also tell Stripe what to do with a subscription once all retries have failed — for example, cancel it, mark it as unpaid, or leave it past due. The exact options are in your Stripe Billing settings.
Put together, that’s a real dunning system, included with Stripe Billing. Our guide to Stripe dunning emails walks through these settings one by one.
What StripeReport Adds on Top
StripeReport connects to your Stripe account read-only. It can’t move money, issue refunds, or change anything in Stripe. On the Pro plan, StripeReport’s Stripe dunning adds:
- Emails in your business’s voice. Within the hour a payment fails, StripeReport sends an email in your business’s name with the decline reason and a secure Stripe link to pay. You can edit every email.
- Wording that matches the decline reason. “Your card has expired” and “your bank declined the charge” need different words. The email adapts to reasons like insufficient funds, an expired card, or a bank decline.
- A clear schedule. First email within the hour, then follow-ups on day 3 and day 7. Emails stop the moment the customer pays — whether that’s through the link or a Smart Retry.
- Card expiry warnings. Card expiry emails go out 3 weeks and 3 days before a card expires ahead of the next renewal, so the payment doesn’t fail in the first place.
- A “before you go” email. When a subscriber sets their subscription to cancel, they get an email while they still have access.
- A win-back email. One win-back email 7 days after a subscription ends, with an optional offer or coupon.
- Your own address. Emails can come from your own email address, and replies go to you.
- Money saved, per email. You can see how much money each email saved. StripeReport also stops emailing addresses that bounce.
- A daily report that names names. Every morning, by email and Slack, you get yesterday’s revenue, MRR and churn, plus who signed up, who cancelled, and whose payment failed, by name.
What StripeReport doesn’t do matters just as much. It doesn’t retry payments — Stripe’s Smart Retries keep doing that. It has no card-update page of its own; it uses Stripe’s secure pages. It has no cancel-flow screens inside your app, no SMS, and no A/B testing.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Stripe built-in | StripeReport (Pro) |
|---|---|---|
| Payment retries | Yes, Smart Retries | No — leaves retries to Stripe |
| Failed-payment emails | Yes, standard emails sent by Stripe | Yes, in your business’s voice, fully editable |
| Decline-reason wording | Check your Stripe Billing settings | Yes (insufficient funds, expired card, bank decline) |
| Timing control | Retry schedule set in Billing settings | Within the hour, day 3, day 7; stops when paid |
| Card expiry warnings | Yes, expiring card emails | Yes, 3 weeks and 3 days before |
| “Before you go” email | No | Yes |
| Win-back email | No | Yes, one email 7 days after ending, optional offer |
| Emails from your own address | Branded with your logo; check Stripe’s settings for sending options | Yes, replies go to you |
| See money recovered | Check your Stripe Dashboard | Yes, per email |
| Daily report of who failed | Look up failed payments in the Dashboard | Yes, by name, every morning by email and Slack |
| Cost | Part of Stripe Billing; check Stripe’s pricing | Priced by MRR, from $49/month under $10k |
Two notes on the table. First, Stripe changes its settings from time to time, so where we’ve written “check your settings,” that’s because the answer depends on what your account shows today. Second, the daily report is also on StripeReport’s cheaper Reports plan ($14.99/month or $99/year), which includes one-tap failed-payment reminders you send by hand. Automatic recovery emails need Pro.
Is Stripe’s Built-In Dunning Enough?
For many small businesses, yes — at least at first. If you have a few dozen subscribers, turn on Smart Retries and Stripe’s customer emails, and check your failed payments yourself each week. When a payment fails, a short personal note from the founder often works better than anything automated.
Stripe’s built-in tools start to feel thin when:
- You have too many subscribers to follow up on every failed payment by hand.
- You want the email to sound like you, explain why the payment failed, and come from your own address.
- You want to reach people who are about to cancel, or who already have — not just people whose card failed.
- You want to know how much money the emails brought back, so you can judge whether they’re working.
- Failed payments are a big part of your churn. Our explainer on involuntary churn shows how to measure that.
A simple test: add up the revenue from failed payments that were never recovered over the last three months. Here’s a hypothetical example. Say 6 subscribers at $40/month quietly churned after failed payments. That’s $240 of MRR gone, or $2,880 a year if none of them come back. If a tool would win back even a few of them, it likely pays for itself. If the number is tiny, stick with Stripe for now.
How to Set Them Up Together
StripeReport and Stripe’s built-in dunning are designed to sit side by side. Here’s the setup we recommend:
- Keep Smart Retries on. StripeReport doesn’t retry payments, so Stripe’s retries are still doing important work. Leave your retry settings as they are.
- Turn off Stripe’s own failed-payment emails. If both systems email the customer, they’ll get two messages about the same failed payment. That’s confusing and looks careless. Switch off Stripe’s failed-payment customer emails in your Billing settings once StripeReport’s are live.
- Decide on expiring card emails. The same logic applies. If you use StripeReport’s card expiry warnings, consider turning off Stripe’s expiring card emails so customers aren’t warned twice.
- Keep Stripe’s hosted pages. StripeReport’s emails link to Stripe’s secure pages for payment, so there’s nothing to change there.
- Check your end-of-retries setting. Decide what Stripe should do with a subscription after the final retry. StripeReport’s day 7 email works best if the subscription is still recoverable at that point.
- Edit the emails and set your sending address. Read each email, adjust the wording to sound like you, and send from your own address so replies land in your inbox.
For the full recovery playbook, see our guide to Stripe failed payment recovery. If you’re weighing other tools too, our roundup of dunning management software compares the wider market.
FAQ
What is Stripe dunning?
It’s the set of tools inside Stripe Billing for recovering failed subscription payments: Smart Retries, optional emails to customers about failed payments and expiring cards, hosted pages where customers can pay or update their card, and settings for what happens to a subscription after the final retry.
Does StripeReport replace Stripe Smart Retries?
No. StripeReport doesn’t retry payments. Smart Retries keep running in Stripe, and StripeReport handles contacting the customer. When a retry succeeds, StripeReport’s emails stop.
Should I turn off Stripe’s failed payment emails?
If you’re using StripeReport’s recovery emails, yes — otherwise customers get two emails about the same problem. Keep Smart Retries on. If you’re not using another tool, leave Stripe’s emails on; they’re much better than sending nothing.
How much does StripeReport cost compared to Stripe’s built-in dunning?
Stripe’s recovery tools are part of Stripe Billing; check Stripe’s pricing for Billing fees. StripeReport’s automatic recovery emails are on the Pro plan, priced by your monthly Stripe revenue, starting at $49/month under $10k MRR. Both plans have a 3-day free trial with no card needed. See all plans on our pricing page, or read more about automated Stripe dunning with StripeReport.