When should I send an expiring card reminder?

Updated

The short answer

Send it based on the next renewal date, not the card's expiry date. If the card will expire before the next payment, email about three weeks before that payment, then once more a few days before if the card still hasn't been updated. If the card lasts past the next renewal, there's nothing to send yet.

Why the renewal date matters more

A card works until the last day of its expiry month. What you care about is whether it will still work on the day you charge it.

On a monthly plan, a card that expires at the end of March is a problem for the April renewal. On an annual plan, a card that expires in March is a problem for a renewal in, say, September, months later. Timing reminders from the expiry date alone means annual customers get warned far too early, or monthly ones too late.

A simple schedule

  1. Every day, find subscriptions whose card expires before their next renewal.
  2. About three weeks before that renewal, send a friendly heads-up with a link to update the card.
  3. About three days before the renewal, send a short last reminder, only if the card still hasn't changed.
  4. Stop as soon as the card is updated.

Common mistakes

  • Emailing at the start of the expiry month, when the next charge is still weeks or months off.
  • Warning every customer whose card expires this year, which trains people to ignore you.
  • Sending more than two or three reminders for something that hasn't gone wrong yet.
  • Forgetting that some cards get updated automatically, and not checking again before each email.

Related questions

Is a month ahead too early?

It can be. People tend to put it off and forget. Around three weeks gives enough time, and a second reminder a few days before catches the rest.

What if a renewal is only a few days away when I notice?

Send one short reminder straight away. It's better than nothing, and if the payment still fails your failed payment emails take over.

Do annual subscribers need a different schedule?

No, the same rule works because it's based on the renewal date. Annual subscribers simply qualify less often, but for higher amounts.